Best Pizza in Toronto: A Local’s Slice Guide

If you’re searching for the best pizza in Toronto, you’re not alone — it’s one of the city’s hottest debates. Whether you crave a classic New York fold, a Neapolitan blistered crust, or a slice that tastes like home after a night out, Toronto’s pizza scene seriously delivers. I’ve scrolled every Reddit thread, listened to locals, and taste-tested a few pies myself.

Here’s a list that nails every search intent from best pizza toronto to top pizza downtown Toronto — real spots Torontonians actually eat at.

By VITALIY PAVLYSH OCTOBER 25, 2025  

Why Toronto Pizza Hits Different 

Toronto doesn’t just do good pizza — it does every style of pizza. Think Ossington’s trendy slices, Dovercourt’s low-key windows, and cozy sit-downs that turn dinner into a ritual.

On r/askTO, locals kept repeating the same names:
“Stick to these: Badiali, Descendant, Mac’s, North of Brooklyn — you won’t be disappointed..”

So yeah, here’s the shortlist that keeps the city talking

1. Pizzeria Badiali (181 Dovercourt Rd) — NYC-Style Royalty

If there’s one name that dominates “best pizza in Toronto” lists, it’s Badiali. A small, walk-up window with big flavour, Badiali nails the New-York-style slice: thin, crisp edges, a bit of chew, and the perfect fold.

Must-try: Plain cheese slice (for that sauce-to-crust perfection) or the vodka slice when it’s on.

Vibe: West Queen West energy — people line up, chat, and show off their slice on Insta before that first bite.

Pro tip: Go early. It gets busy from lunch through late night.

Badiali basically defines the “best pizza downtown Toronto” vibe — iconic, simple, and loved by everyone who swears they’ve found the one.

2. North of Brooklyn Pizzeria (Queen & Palmerston) — Wood-Fired Romance

This spot is the place for classic New York slices — giant, cheesy, fold-and-go perfection.

Try: The NY Cheese or Kale & Bacon (iconic combo).

Style: Thin crust, oversized slices, zero fluff.

Why locals love it: Reliable, quick, and open late enough for post-bar cravings.

If your search is “best pizza places Toronto” or “best pizzeria Toronto”, North of Brooklyn always makes the cut.

3. Mac’s Pizza (759 Dovercourt Rd) — Chill Hidden Gem

Tucked near Ossington but without the hype, Mac’s Pizza is a local favourite that Redditors call underrated but amazing.

Vibe: Laid-back neighbourhood joint.

Slice style: NY-inspired with a slightly thicker, toastier base.

Try: The white pie or pepperoni cup slice.

Perfect if you want “best Toronto pizza” quality but hate waiting in line for it.

4. Bar Sugo (1279 Bloor St W) — Big Slice Energy

For those nights when you want a pizza that feels like an experience. Bar Sugo’s Neapolitan-style pies come with that signature charred crust and super fresh toppings.

Try: The Hot Soppressata or the Margherita.

Setting: Cozy date-night vibe with an Italian wine list.

Why go: It’s a little fancier — fits that “famous pizza Toronto” search perfectly.

5. Descendant Detroit Style Pizza (1168 Queen St E) — Deep, Crispy, Legendary

Welcome to the east side — Descendant is a Detroit-style cult classic that flips the whole Toronto pizza conversation.

Try: Truff-Gh (mushroom, ricotta, white truffle oil) or Soppressata 911 (for a spicy hit).

Style: Detroit-style — thick, airy dough, caramelized cheese edges, baked in a steel pan.

Why it stands out: Every bite is crispy on the outside and cloud-soft inside.

Perfect for: When “best pizza Toronto” means deep, indulgent, unforgettable.

This is the spot locals mention when someone asks for “something different, but still the best.”

Final Slice

Toronto’s pizza scene is straight-up world-class. Whether you’re grabbing a quick slice at Badiali, ordering Maker for movie night, or making Bar Sugo your Friday date spot — there’s no missing here.

Start with Badiali, then grab Maker Pizza, and thank me later.
And if you’ve got a secret favourite? Drop it in the comments. We’re always down for a taste test (for research purposes, obviously).